Ali Karim was a Board Member of Bouchercon [The World Crime & Mystery Convention] and co-chaired programming for Bouchercon Raleigh, North Carolina in 2015. He is Assistant Editor of Shots eZine, British correspondent for The Rap Sheet and writes and reviews for many US magazines & Ezines.
As a book reviewer who focuses on Crime and Horror Fiction most of the time, digressions help cleanse and refresh the mind especially when stumbling upon a work of art. This graphic novel ‘Ode to Joy’ is a work of art that celebrates life in a very dark world.
What commences as a family reflection, as a remembrance of a dark past illustrated and written in a pictorial style, soon becomes something more.
Central to this graphic novel is the young boy Ib Katznelson and his family, including Grandparents. Starting in 1943 Copenhagen, despite the rise of Nazi Germany spreading across Europe unfurling the so-called ‘final solution’ – the Katznelson family feel sheltered. That feeling of safety does not last long. Attempting to flee Denmark, the family pay a people-smuggler ‘M’ their total savings to take them by car [and then boat] to Sweden. Tragically the mysterious ‘M’ is working with the Gestapo, so soon the family is arrested.
The Katznelson family are split up and transported across Europe. The boy Ib and his Mother end up prisoners within the notorious Ravensbruck facility, but eventually settle in Theresienstadt Concentration Camp near Prague where they are reunited with other members of their family.
There is disease, anxiety and the horrors including [the small boy] Ib being separated from his mother [and family] due to diphtheria and the regime. The graphic imagery is a cross between Fritz Lang, Bauhaus, Andy Warhol, and New Wave Expressionism funnelled into illustrative collages and elliptical lettering so that the calligraphy meshes with the pictures – combining artistry with despair.
The horrors and cruelty that the family endures as captives of the Nazi Regime becomes at times unbearable. The prisoners resort to art, be it music, theatre, singing, dance, cabaret, opera, painting and any artistic endeavour to lift the spirits – especially for the children imprisoned in these horrific circumstances. The Camp authorities allow such activity [not for lifting of the prisoner’s spirits but] to act as a cynical cover to show the outside world that the Jews held within the walls of this Ghettoised Camp are happy. Prior to a visitation / inspection by the Red Cross, thousands of inmates are sent East [for extermination] in order to make the Camp appear less crowded to appease [aka ‘fool’] the Danish authorities.
The graphic novel has a patchwork of different narrators and styles that relay the story, which has family and artistry as a form of escape at its core.
The title is therefore an apt contrast to the horrors that the imprisoned Jews endured. The effect on the reader is to unsettle, disturb as much as celebrate the humanity of people trying their hardest to protect their children, and therefore their future.
Like Maus by Art Spiegelman, when I came to the end of the novel, I sat in total silence contemplating the darkness in humanity and perplexed at how people can endure such horrors.
Bravo Sophie Herxheimer and Sarah Gavron for producing such an important book. It is essential reading for children [and adults] in a world that has some voices blindly cheering for fascism.
Empathy for others starts with education and ends with reminders of the evils in the past, and books such as ‘Ode to Joy’ assist in this urgent endeavour.