IN THE SHADOW OF GOTHAM

Written by Stefanie Pintoff

Review written by Sue Lord


IN THE SHADOW OF GOTHAM
Penguin
RRP: £6.99
Released: 2nd December 2010
Pbk

 

I found the first sentence of this book somewhat lumpy; “The scream that pierced the dull yellow November sky was preternaturally high-pitched.”  I was predisposed not to enjoy the read.

In the Shadow of Gotham is a simple murder mystery set in the early 1900’s. Hannah, the fiancée of New York Detective Simon Ziele was drowned in the General Slocum ferry disaster. Ziele has transferred to the quiet town of Dobson, north of New York hoping to put his recent past behind him. Sarah Wingate, a young woman staying with her aunt, is brutally murdered in her bedroom on a winter afternoon. This is the first murder in Dodson for years and the type of crime Ziele had hoped to leave behind. But now he needs to investigate the deceits, lies and motives that have led to Sarah’s death. The investigation takes Ziele back to New York. He is contacted by Columbia University’s noted criminologist; Alistair Sinclair, who thinks that the murderer could be one of his patients, one Michael Fromley.

Simon Ziele and Alistair Sinclair must find the murderer before he strikes again. There are shades of early C.S.I with the use of forensic evidence and descriptions of early criminology were fascinating. This was a time when scientists were trying to understand criminal behaviour.

Ziele is the first person narrator, he is a tedious character, flat and lifeless.  The only time he comes to life is when angry and frustrated. The story is held back by extraneous detail. Ziele describes everything, even the perfectly obvious, as in the Chinese food scene, which, as with a lot of the exposition is something of a data dump.

Alistair Sinclair is a professor at Columbia University. He is a wealthy eccentric and criminology is his hobby. He makes an affective contrast to the rather limp rag, Ziele. They do most of the detecting together.

The plot is based on a coincidence. The narrator, Ziele and the reader know early on that the investigation is going in the wrong direction. It takes a long, long, long, time for them to ‘catch up.’

The end-of-chapter habit of foreshadowing happened too many times. It was trite i.e. “And the truth, when we learned it, would be even worse than I imagined.” “Would draw upon our every power of deduction to unravel.” “We should pray we are not mistaken – and not too late.”

There is a good mystery at the heart of the story, but the ‘voice’ of the novel takes away any tension or suspense and there is no real sense of place. If you like ponderous eighteenth century writing you will probably like this book

 

 

 

 

 

medical abortion pill online buy abortion pills online cytotec abortion pill buy online
i dream my husband cheated on me why do wife cheat how many women cheat on husbands
buy viagra online canada how to buy viagra for cheap viagra size
why do women cheat on their husbands husbands that cheat marriage affairs
coupons prescriptions site prescription coupon card
discount coupons for prescriptions printable viagra coupon coupons for prescriptions
can i take motrin and tylenol can i take motrin and tylenol can i take motrin and tylenol
different types of abortion website-knowledge.com coupons discounts
coupon for bystolic click forest patient assistance
abortion costs bartsha.cz birth control
free prescription drug discount card cialis coupon cialis savings and coupons
discount coupon for cialis datum-digital.com cialis coupon card
abortion clinics pictures of abortions abortion pill procedure
amoxicillin-rnp achi-kochi.com amoxicillin 1000 mg
cialis.com coupons site cialis discount coupons online
cialis coupons from lilly coupons cialis free coupon for cialis
abortion pill stories the abortion pill anti abortion facts
clomid proviron clomid tapasztalatok clomid testosterone
amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat
cost of abortions klitvejen.dk abortion pill quotes
amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicillin-rnp amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat
priligy kokemuksia priligy priligy resepti
online coupons sites discount codes website for coupons
herbal abortion pill how much are abortions abortion pill information
addiyan chuk chuk thebaileynews.com addyi menopause
information about abortion pill supermaxsat.com aspiration abortion
amoxicillin dermani haqqinda amoxicillin amoxicillin 500 mg
viagra torta viagra kamagra cialis viagra helyett
cialis 5 mg allindiasweetsrestaurant.com cialis nedir
what is an abortion clinic abortion stories of regret where to do abortion
discount drug coupon masykur.web.id internet drug coupons
naltrexone implant australia go who can prescribe naltrexone
whats ldn centaurico.com low dose ldn
vivitrol injection blog.admissionnews.com implant treatment for alcoholism
low dose naltrexone allergies naltrexone cocaine naltrexone 50 mg tablet
depade naltrexone link revia and alcohol


Home
Book Reviews
Features
Interviews
News
Columns
Authors
Competitions
Blog
Shop
About Us
Contact Us

Privacy Policy | Contact Shots Editor

THIS WEBSITE IS © SHOTS COLLECTIVE. NOT TO BE REPRODUCED ELECTRONICALLY EITHER WHOLLY OR IN PART WITHOUT PRIOR PERMISSION OF THE EDITOR.